The rattiest of all Rats (elseinane) wrote in hp_la,
The rattiest of all Rats
elseinane
hp_la

  • Mood:

Movie discussion

Not everyone has seen HBP yet - so under a cut!

DO NOT READ THE COMMENTS UNLESS YOU WANT TO BE SPOILED!
THIS IS YOUR WARNING!

As always - this is one person's opinion in bullet points. Not rife with profundity or deep insight, that would require more time and another viewing. =D

The Great
Young and Not-As-Young Tom Riddle - just dead on
Lavender Brown - perfectly cringe-worthy
The Cave - W00T if a bit restrained
Draco - OMG YES - Tom Felton hits one out of the park!
Weasely's Wizard Wheezes! Just... wonderful!
Slughorn - inspired by Broadbent; I like Horace more now. The addition of the "fish" story.... deeply powerful. Kudos.
Slug Club dessert scene - Lothario!Cormac just... awesome
Sectumsempra Scene - well done, if the gravity was trampled on
Drunk!Hermione - squee worthy. So glad Emma's acting chops have developed over eyebrow acting!!!!
Luna - Evanna is Luna. Enough said.


The Not-So-Great
Harry/Ginny - was just... odd
Neville - WHY DID THEY MAKE YOU A WAITER???
The whole attack on Hogwarts? ummm.... where did it go?


The WTF?
Why did Narcissa have Cruella de Vil's hair?
Um.... don't we sort of need to know about Slytherin's locket, the diadem, et al? Isn't that sort of... A MAJOR PLOT POINT?
Hello? Dobby? Where is my Dobby?


A very rough list... Agree? Disagree??
Tags: movie
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 4 comments